per amica silentia lunae

or, across the ferny brae with the evil voodoo celt

Previous Entry Share Next Entry
interesting article on terrorism
dream
evcelt
Posted mainly for my own reference: Terrorism: a Brief For Americans

I thought this was well-reasoned and exceptionally clear, although I don't agree with all of the conclusions- for example, I think the author downplays the role of ideology and religion as a primary motivating factor, and I think some of his speculations about the cause of WWII are a bit naive... Still, very interesting...

  • 1
Yeah, anyone who doesn't realize that it's fanaticism at the heart of it all is really missing the boat.

Well, I he makes a point of saying that fanaticism (the quote he uses calls it "fundamentalism", but it's pretty clear what he means) is a huge motivating force and what makes terrorists so hard to deal with directly. But I think he needs to give more weight to it as a force of causation, as well.

I don't agree that fanaticism is exclusively "at the heart of it all". But it belongs there along with the other factors that he cites.

Still, I think his suggestions for modifying and expanding out policies are worth consideration and qualified adoption.

Yeah, I agree with your assessment of this paper, very interesting reading, a tad naive and simplistic in some circumstances. But I think his views on the politics and our responses and vice versa are spot-on. Analysis as hindsight is of course 20/20; its the implementation thats difficult and not something I see happening for at least 2 years...

Well, I think he is wrong on winning the jihadist war sooner. I think it will take decades.

  • 1
?

Log in